Directors in the Loop? Responsible Corporate Governance for the Era of AI
Contenido principal del artículo
Resumen
The relationship between corporate success and technological progress has never been more overt, with digital businesses and products proliferating at extraordinary pace and scale. Of the many innovations to have emerged, Artificial Intelligence (AI) entails arguably the greatest disruption to the corporation, economy, law and society, and thus represents a singular challenge for the company director. AI is becoming pervasive, driving profitability and competitive differentiation, yet its profound socioeconomic externalities are provoking attention on corporate governance and the nexus between private value and public interest. At the same time, a lack of contextualisation for AI in contemporary regulatory frameworks creates ongoing legal uncertainties for industry and society. This paper critically assesses the effectiveness of corporate law and governance in this context, and argues—primarily from the Australian perspective—that directors are not adequately prepared to govern AI for long-term corporate value. Part 1 descriptively examines the distinctive challenge of AI governance, contextualising the subsequent normative arguments. Part 2 critically analyses present-day board and legal effectiveness in the governance of AI for shareholder and stakeholder benefit. Part 3 explores “responsible AI” governance reforms, contending substantial legal and normative changes are required in future. AI will effect a momentous socioeconomic transformation, promising great benefits but carrying equally profound risks; therefore, the paper concludes that while an appropriate regulatory framework for AI is now essential, the director has a critical role to pre-emptively adopt “corporate techno-social responsibility” principles and establish a new model of responsible governance to redefine corporate value for this most disruptive era.
Descargas
Detalles del artículo
Citas
Acemoğlu, Daron, ‘What Are the Dangers of Unregulated AI? An Expert Explains’ World Economic Forum (WEF) (Web Page, 1 December 2021)
Armour, John and Horst Eidenmüeller, ‘Self-Driving Corporations?’ (Law Working Paper No. 475/2019, European Corporate Governance Institute (ECGI), August 2019)
Attorney-General’s Department, ‘Privacy Act Review: Discussion Paper–Published Responses’, Attorney-General’s Department (Web Page)
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) ‘Trivago to Pay $44.7 Million in Penalties for Misleading Consumers Over Hotel Room Rates’ ACCC (Media Release, 22 April 2021)
Australian Government, ‘Australia’s Artificial Intelligence Ethics Framework’ Department of Industry Science and Resources (Web Page, 7 November 2019)
Australian Government, ‘Positioning Australia as a Leader in Digital Economy Regulation: Automated Decision Making and AI Regulation: Issues Paper’ (March 2022)
Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), Human Rights and Technology: Final Report 2021 (AHRC, 2021)
Australian Institute of Corporate Directors (AICD), Director Tools: Role of the Board (1 January 2020)
Australian Institute of Company Directors (AICD), Driving Innovation: The Boardroom Gap (AICD and University of Sydney Business School, September 2019)
Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), ASIC Corporate Plan 2022–26: Focus 2022–23 (August 2022)
Bankewitz, Max, Carl Åberg and Christine Teuchert, ‘Digitalization and Boards of Directors: A New Era of Corporate Governance?’ (2016) 5(2) Business and Management Research 58
Barnes, Lisa, ‘The Albatross Around the Neck of Company Directors: A Journey Through Case Law, Legislation and Corporate Governance’ (2013) 12(1) JLFM 2
Blakkarly, Jarni, ‘Kmart, Bunnings and The Good Guys Using Facial Recognition Technology in Stores’ Choice (Web Page, 12 July 2022)
Board Agenda, ‘Leadership in AI 2021: Boards, Barriers and New Beginnings’ (Board Agenda, Mazars and INSEAD Corporate Governance Centre, Research Report, 2021)
Boza, Pal and Theodoros Evgeniou, ‘Implementing AI Principles: Frameworks, Processes, and Tools’ (Working Paper, INSEAD, April 2021)
Brynjolfsson, Erik, Daniel Rock and Chad Syverson, ‘Unpacking the AI-Productivity Paradox: Technology Expectations and Economic Statistics Are Clashing for Now—But the Reality Is More Promising than It Appears’ MIT Sloan Management Review (Web Page, 16 January 2018)
Bughin, Jacques and Eric Hazan, ‘Can Artificial Intelligence Help Society as Much as It Helps Business?’ McKinsey Quarterly (Web Page, 6 August 2019)
Bughin, Jacques et al, ‘“Tech for Good”: Using Technology to Smooth Disruption and Improve Well-Being’ McKinsey Global Institute (Web Page, 15 May 2019)
Burridge, Nicky, ‘AI Takes Its Place in The Boardroom: Directors’ Tasks Are Becoming Increasingly Automated; Are Fully Autonomous Companies Next?’ NikkeiAsia (Web Page, 25 May 2017)
Callaway, Ewen, ‘The Entire Protein Universe: AI Predicts Shape of Nearly Every Known Protein’ Nature (online 29 July 2022)
Chiu, Iris H-Y and Ernest W K Lim, ‘Managing Corporations’ Risk in Adopting Artificial Intelligence: A Corporate Responsibility Paradigm’ (2021) 20(2) Washington University Global Studies Law Review 347
Cihon, Peter, Jonas Schuett and Seth D Baum, ‘Corporate Governance of Artificial Intelligence in the Public Interest’ (2021) 12(275) Information 1
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), Our Future World: Global Megatrends Impacting the Way We Live Over Coming Decades (July 2022)
Davis, Nicholas, Lauren Perry and Edward Santow, Facial Recognition Technology: Towards a Model Law (Human Technology Institute Report, September 2022)
Diamantis, Mihailis, ‘Who Pays for AI Injury?’ Oxford Business Law Blog (Blog Post, 4 May 2020)
Dignam, Alan, ‘Artificial Intelligence, Tech Corporate Governance and the Public Interest Regulatory Response’ (2020) 31(1) Cambridge Journal of Regions Economy and Society 37
Durkin, Patrick, ‘Six Business Leaders Predict the Future for Boards’ Australian Financial Review (online 21 September 2021)
Eccles, Robert G and Miriam Vogel, ‘Board Responsibility for Artificial Intelligence Oversight’ Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance (Blog Post, 5 January 2022)
Edelman, ‘2019 Edelman AI Survey’ (Survey Results Report, 2019)
Enriques, Luca and Dirk A Zetzsche, ‘Corporate Technologies and the Tech Nirvana Fallacy’ (2020) 72(1) Hastings Law Journal 55
Evans, Gary L, ‘Technology and the Corporate Board 2020 and Beyond’ in Richard Leblanc (ed), The Handbook of Board Governance: A Comprehensive Guide for Public, Private and Not-for-Profit Board Members (Wiley, 2nd ed, 2020) 210
Eyers, James, ‘Why Westpac’s Board Is Obsessed with Artificial Intelligence’ Australian Financial Review (online 21 September 2022)
Featherstone, Tony, ‘Governance in the New Machine Age’ AICD (Web Page, 24 March 2017)
Fenwick, Mark and Erik P M Vermeulen, ‘Technology and Corporate Governance: Blockchain, Crypto, and Artificial Intelligence’ (Law Working Paper No. 424/2018, ECGI, November 2018)
Fenwick, Mark and Erik P M Vermeulen, ‘The End of the Corporation’ (Law Working Paper No. 482/2019, ECGI, November 2019)
Ford, Jolyon, ‘Ethical AI: The Role of Law and Regulation’ (21 April 2021)
Fuhrman, Patrick and John G Mooney, ‘Business Adoption of Artificial Intelligence: An Analysis of Scope, Intent and Realized Business Benefits’ (2021) 24(1) Graziadio Business Review (Web Page)
Gartner, ‘Gartner Says Nearly Half of CIOs Are Planning to Deploy Artificial Intelligence’ Gartner Newsroom (Web Page, 13 February 2018)
Governance Institute of Australia (GIA), Driving the Digital Revolution: A Guide for Boards (GIA, May 2022)
Gramitto Ricci, Sergio Alberto, ‘Artificial Agents in Corporate Boardrooms’ (2020) 105(3) Cornell Law Review 869
Hanrahan, Pamela, ‘Corporate Governance in These “Exciting Times”’ (2017) 32 Australian Journal of Corporate Law 142
Hickey, Alex, ‘AI Sits in on Salesforce’s Board Meetings and Has Something to Say’ CIO Dive (Web Page, 26 January 2018)
Hilb, Michael, ‘Toward Artificial Governance? The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Shaping the Future of Corporate Governance’ (2020) 2 Journal of Management and Governance 851
Hill, Jennifer G, ‘Legal Personhood and Liability for Flawed Corporate Cultures’ (Law Working Paper No. 431/2018, ECGI, June 2020) < https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3309697>
International Standards Organisation (ISO), ‘ISO/IEC 38507:2022: Information Technology—Governance of IT: Governance Implications of the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Organizations’ ISO (Web Page, April 2022)
Johnson, Khari, ‘When AI Hurts People, Who Is Held Responsible?’ VentureBeat (Web Page, 12 October 2020)
Kalmanath, Akshaya, ‘The Perennial Quest for Board Independence: Artificial Intelligence to the Rescue?’ (16 May 2019) Albany Law Review (forthcoming)
Korinek, Anton and Avital Balwit, ‘Aligned with Whom? Direct and Social Goals for AI Systems’ (Center on Regulation and Markets Working Paper #2, Brookings, May 2022)
Land, Molly K and Jay D Aronson, ‘Human Rights and Technology: New Challenges for Justice and Accountability’ (2020) 16 Annual Review of Law and Social Science 223
Laptev, Vasiliy Andreevich and Daria Rinatovna Feyzrakhmanova, ‘Digitalization of Institutions of Corporate Law: Current Trends and Future Prospects’ (2021) 10(93) Laws 1
Lowry, John, ‘The Irreducible Core of the Duty of Care, Skill and Diligence of Company Directors: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Healey’ (2012) 75(2) The Modern Law Review 249
McKinsey and Company, ‘Global AI Survey: AI Proves Its Worth, But Few Scale Impact’ McKinsey (Web Page, 22 November 2019)
Moses, Lyria Bennett, ‘Recurring Dilemmas: The Law’s Race to Keep up with Technological Change’ [2007] 2007(2) University of Illinois Journal of Law, Technology & Policy 243
Möslein, Florian, ‘Robots in the Boardroom: Artificial Intelligence and Corporate Law’, in Woodrow Barfield and Ugo Pagallo (eds), Research Handbook on the Law of Artificial Intelligence (Edward Elgar, 2018) 649
Nettle, Justice Geoffrey, ‘The Changing Position and Duties of Company Directors’ (2018) 41 Melbourne University Law Review 1402
Nimdzi Insights, ‘Artificial Intelligence, Localization, Winners, Losers, Heroes, Spectators, and You’ (Nimdzi Insights and Pactera EDGE, Whitepaper, 2019)
Perrigo, Billy, ‘An Artificial Intelligence Helped Write This Play: It May Contain Racism’ Time (online 23 August 2021)
Petrin, Martin, ‘Corporate Management in the Age of AI’ (University College London (UCL) Working Paper Series No.3/2019)
Picciau, Chiara, ‘The (Un)Predictable Impact of Technology on Corporate Governance’ (2021) 17(1) Hastings Business Law Journal 67
Roose, Kevin, ‘We Need to Talk About How Good AI Is Getting’ New York Times (online 24 August 2022)
Selbst, Andrew D, ‘An Institutional View of Algorithmic Impact Assessments’ (2021) 35(1) Harvard Journal of Law & Technology 117
Siegmann, Charlotte and Markus Anderljung, The Brussels Effect and Artificial Intelligence: How EU Regulation Will Impact the Global AI Market (Report, Centre for the Governance of AI, August 2022)
Sim, Bérengère, ‘Shareholders Quiz Google on AI risks’ Financial News (Web Page, 18 June 2019)
Townshend, Pete, ‘How is AI Regulated Around the World?’ SmartFrame Blog (Blog Post, 28 April 2022)
Valentine, Elizabeth L H, ‘Enterprise Technology Governance: New Information and Technology Core Competencies for Boards of Directors’ (PhD Thesis, Queensland University of Technology, 2016)
Valentine, Elizabeth, Steven De Haes and Anant Joshi, ‘Responsive Governance in a Digital World: The Need to Up-skill’ in Richard Leblanc (ed), The Handbook of Board Governance: A Comprehensive Guide for Public, Private and Not-for-Profit Board Members (Wiley, 2nd ed, 2020) 225
Voogt, Thea and Martie-Louise Verreynne, ‘Director Appointments: Expressing Board Care and Diligence’ (2018) 41(4) University of NSW Law Journal 1335
Watermark Search International, 2021 Board Diversity Index (Watermark Search International and Governance Institute of Australia, 2021)
Weill, Peter et al, ‘It Pays to Have a Digitally Savvy Board’ (2019) 60(3) MIT Sloan Management Review 41
Williams, Shannon, ‘Only 22% of Australians Trust AI Implementation: Study’ IT Brief (Web Page, 17 March 2022)
World Economic Forum (WEF), Empowering AI Leadership: AI C-Suite Toolkit (January 2022)
B Cases
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) v Trivago NV (No 2) [2022] FCA 417
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) v Trivago NV [2020] FCA 16
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Healey [2011] FCA 717
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Clark (2003) 57 NSWLR 113
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Commissioner Initiated Investigation into Clearview AI, Inc. (Privacy) [2021] AICmr 54 (14 October 2021)
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, Commissioner Initiated Investigation into 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd (Privacy) (Corrigendum dated 12 October 2021) [2021] AICmr 50 (29 September 2021)
Trivago N.V. v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2020] FCAFC 185
